Policy@Manchester Articles

Expert insight, analysis and comment on key public policy issues

  • All Posts
  • UK Politics
  • Energy and Environment
  • Growth and Inclusion
  • Health and Social Care
  • Urban
  • Science and Engineering
Policy@Manchester Articles: All posts
You are here: Home / All posts / Oxbridge Universities are the go to places for academic research and expertise: but it’s not the whole story
Banner image with Policy@Manchester visual branding

Oxbridge Universities are the go to places for academic research and expertise: but it’s not the whole story

Carole Talbot By Carole Talbot Filed Under: All posts, Whitehall Watch Posted: May 19, 2015

Can ‘outsider’ universities break the Oxbridge stranglehold on the Civil Service? Carole Talbot explores…

It’s well understood that Whitehall Civil Servants go to Oxford and Cambridge Universities more often than elsewhere. And, many of the linkages into these universities are based on civil servants having attended one of the Oxbridge Colleges themselves and that the relationships between ex students and tutors form the basis of the evaluation of academic expertise.

While this situation might persist recent research suggests the dominance of Oxbridge is much less important. Firstly, the social class structure within Whitehall has been changing for some time. Between 1998 and 2011, for example, the number of Oxbridge graduates entering the civil service fast stream fell from 34.5% to 26.0%. Add to this the fact that 23% of the senior civil service are external recruits from the private, voluntary and wider public sector, see this article by Colin Talbot. Therefore serious inroads have been made to the dominance of Oxbridge educated civil servants.

Furthermore, new survey research with senior civil servants suggests while Oxbridge remains an important source of research and expertise it is not the whole story and the links between Whitehall and Academics are in fact very widespread and include universities across the country, as this report shows.

Further analysis provides findings from the question which asked Civil Servants to list up to five universities as sources of the best academic research and expertise from their perspective ‘within the UK’. What we found was that, yes, Oxford and Cambridge are highly valued for their research and expertise. Oxford was selected 47 times and Cambridge 53. Their names also appeared in all five positions selected – although there was no attempt to rank universities in the question, if Oxbridge Universities were totally dominant in the market for research and expertise they would likely have occupied more of the 1st and 2nd positions among the 404 selections. The London Colleges counted together were also selected 100 times.  Among the colleges of course there is a wide variation – with the LSE receiving 30 nominations, UCL 23 and Imperial 22 – others many fewer.  Therefore, Oxford, Cambridge and the London Universities counted together received 200 out of the 404 selections.

Slightly over half of the selections were then not for these particular top universities. This suggests that there is a lot of ‘acknowledged’ expertise outside of the London area within Whitehall.  There is a long tail of universities contributing research and expertise, some perhaps having expertise only a few or even one particular area, but they are acknowledged for it. Both via the REF process and among policymakers.

Outside of the London area, The University of Manchester follows with 23, level pegging with UCL, and Warwick University with 19.  The University of Birmingham received 12 and Cranfield University 10. I have presented here all universities which received 10 or above nominations. Therefore, another 64 selections are accounted for which leaves 140 for all other universities across the United Kingdom.

A total of 44 universities share the 140 nominations, sometimes only 1 or 2. They represent a huge variety based on the survey results including Scottish, Welsh and Northern Irish Universities and many specialist institutions too including colleges of art, agriculture, bio medical and veterinary training to highlight just a few of the disciplines acknowledged.

This adds to what was more striking data on the London area dominance drawn from the ‘Who’s Lobbying Database’ in 2013.  This analysis looked at the ‘potential influence’ from Universities lobbying with Parliament and the Government. This data source showed that Parliament is lobbied more than government and implied Parliament is more receptive to lobbying. The sample of 10 academic institutions with a general public policy focus was admittedly small and so cannot be taken as a representative sample. However, the breakdown of the data does show a similar story of the dominance of the so-called Golden Triangle of universities (Oxford, Cambridge, UCL, LSE and Kings College). These account for 77% of Parliamentary appearances and 83% of meetings with Government, see here.

Due to the size of the sample in the above this appears to be slightly exaggerated – it is probable by examining a wider number of universities it would likely show more the story that our new survey data suggests, more impacts but in the form of a ‘long tail’ of a lot with a few impacts each. Our conclusion, that there is broad engagement across universities and the walls of Whitehall are not impervious to sustained attempts from ‘outsiders’ to breakthrough – but it could be hard work.

Tagged With: Cambridge, Civil Service, Golden Triangle, LSE, Oxford University, UCL

About Carole Talbot

Dr Carole Talbot is a Lecturer in Public Policy and Management at Manchester Business School, the University of Manchester. Carole specializes in public management reform, in particular joined-up government, including integration and mergers, public sector performance policy and management, the role of Parliament in scrutiny, local economic development and local, regional and European governance. She has interests in research methods for public policy and has worked for independent consultancy organizations.

Our RSS feed

Receive our latest content and timely updates by subscribing to our RSS feed.

 Subscribe in your reader

More from this author

  • The Political Power of the Business Corporation

Become a contributor

Would you like to write for us on a public policy issue? Get in touch with a member of the team, ask for our editorial guidelines, or access our online training toolkit (UoM login required).

Disclaimer

Articles give the views of the author, and are not necessarily those of The University of Manchester.

Policy@Manchester

Manchester Policy Articles is an initiative from Policy@Manchester. Visit our web site to find out more

Contact Us

policy@manchester.ac.uk
t: +44 (0) 161 275 3038
The University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL, UK

Copyright © 2025 · Policy Blog 2 on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in